Anonymous reported on March 25, 2017 that China, South Korea (SK) and Japan are all developing next generation batteries. SK is developing a submarine that uses Lithium-ion Batteries (LIBs). Anonymous says he used to think that the first fuel cell FC-AIP+ LIBs submarine would be developed as a TKMS + Siemens’ collaboration. But, SK may utilise TKMS' FC-AIP patent first, to create a FC-AIP + LIBs submarine. Of course the safety or reliability of SK LIBs remain unknown.
Insufficient information concerns China and LIBs for diesel-electric submarines to judge when China will install LIBs for the electrical system.
SOUTH KOREAN ARTICLE
After using right-click mouse to translate the following Doga A.comSK article Pete has further translated it to more logical English.
The article’s author, Son Hyojoo hjson@donga.com, for Doga A.com, of March 23, 2017, reports http://news.donga.com/Main/3/all/20170323/83474430/1
"Longer ~" First applied to domestic lithium battery, propulsion power for next generation submarine”
“The first [South Korean (SK)] submarines to be powered by LIBs will be 3 x 3000-class Jang Bogo-IIIs to be deployed by the SK Navy from 2030.
The SK Defense Agency announced that it held a detailed design review (CDR) meeting on July 23, 2016 on the applicability of a LIB system to the Jang Bogo-III (Submarine Placement-II [KSS-III Mark 2s?]). The detailed design review meeting was the final decision stage to determine the feasibility of LIBs for submarine and the possibility of producing a prototype.
"At this meeting, it was decided that the LIB system is suitable as the main propulsion power supply system for the Jang Bogo-III (see Submarine Matters’ reference) B-II. [B-II can be taken to mean Mark 2] " Based on this, SK will lay the foundations for developing the LIB system in earnest.
If the submarine LIBs are successfully developed, performance will improve in many aspects such as energy density, battery life, submersible power, maintenance and so on compared with the lead-acid battery [LAB] system applied to existing SK developed submarines.
Samsung SDI is developing a lithium battery battery by participating in the project led by the next generation submarine project of the radiation agency[?]
[Comment – Is South Korea’s next generation submarine project a [South] Korea Atomic Energy Research Institute (KAERI) “radiation” project? Noting KAERI has a small 100MW reactor design known as “SMART”) This is also noting DSME has “Nuclear Propulsion Ship” on its “New Technology [Maritime] List”].
"The submarine-mounted lithium battery system is being developed in advanced submarine operating countries such as Germany, France and Japan,"said Chung Il-shik, chief of the next-generation submarine business. "We are already developing globally- It is meaningful to utilize it in. "
Doga A.com article Ends
TABLE
Anonymous has created the following Table of Advanced Batteries for Submarine by Generation.
Name | Composition or abbreviation | Energy density [kW/kg] (theoretical) | Note | |
First Generation LIB | Lithium Nickel Cobalt Aluminum Oxide | LiNiCoAlO2 or NCA | 260 | 27SS, 28SS |
Lithium Cobalt Oxide | LiCoO2 or LCO | 200 (1014) | Shinkai 6500 | |
Lithium Nickel Manganese Cobalt Oxide | LiNiMnCoO2 or NMC | 200 | ||
Lithium Manganese Oxide | LiMn2O4 or LMO | 140 (410) | Proto-type by JMSDF | |
Lithium Iron Phosphate | LiFePO4 or LFP | 120 (575) | LFYP (China) is family of LFP | |
Lithium titanate | Li4Ti5O12 or LTO | 80 | CEP- Japan | |
LAB | LAB | 40 | ||
LSB | LSB | (ca.2500) | ||
Second Generation LIB | Lithium Ion Silicate | Li2FeSiO4 | (1584) | High Safety, low cycle performance |
Lithium Manganese Silicate | Li2MnSiO4 | (1485) | High Safety, low cycle performance |
COMMENTS
Anonymous commented: Second gen LIBs (Lithium Ion Silicate or Lithium Manganese Silicate) show excellent properties such as very high energy density and safety. Their main drawback may be low cycle performance. Studies to overcome this issue are being conducted.
Two routes of advanced battery development may be as follows:
Route 1 LABs --- First Gen LIBs --- Second Gen LIBs --- LSBs
Route 2 LABs--- First Gen LIBs --- LSBs
Pete Comment:I think TKMS is doing most of the design work for the KSS-III 3000-class Jang Bogo-III just as TKMS designed the KSS-ls and KSS-IIs. But I think TKMS does not say it is involved in Jang Bogo-III design because of the cruise or ballistic missiles SK will install in Jang Bogo-IIIs. These missiles may be seen (by China and North Korea) as capable of (but not actually carrying) nuclear warheads.
The other German company Siemens might also say it is not helping with FC-AIP for SK because FC-AIP would make the Jang Bogo-III a more efficient missile carrying platform.
Anonymous and Pete